When I was in eighth grade, I went on a school-sponsored trip to Washington, D.C.
The details are fuzzy now, but here’s the gist of it: We were supposed to return on Saturday with the class, but my competitive basketball team added a last-minute weekend tournament. So, I had to get home early along with another teammate who was also in my class. Our parents had our flights switched to Friday, so my friend and I got a taxi (yes, two middle school children getting a taxi) to Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport (DCA) only to have the flight canceled an hour later. Then, we got another taxi (you can’t make this stuff up) across town to Washington Dulles International Airport (IAD) to catch a different flight home. To me, as a mother raising kids in 2026, the idea of my children getting in taxis and flying unaccompanied sounds reckless and possibly illegal.
Flying, like parenthood, has gone through a similar transition. My aviation mentor and dear friend, Grant Bales, grew up flying in the late 1940s/early ’50s. He would often wax nostalgic about flying over friends’ Kentucky farms in his Aeronca Champ, seeing smoke from their chimneys, and landing in their field for a cup of coffee. Can you imagine the alarm bells that would be sounded were we to do that now? Bales also flew his first solo around five hours with no pre-solo stage check or a logbook full of endorsements. By contrast, most of the flight schools I work with now as an FAA designated pilot examiner have at least 10 lessons (approximately 15 hours) in their syllabus before a pilot is soloed. These schools also have a procedure for everything. While increased safeguards do help minimize risk for inexperienced pilots, they also hinder a pilot’s ability to make his or her own aeronautical decisions. Just what are pilots to do when they graduate from these programs and are suddenly expected to keep themselves safe and legal without all the protective scaffolding?
As a DPE, there are three main areas where I see today’s pilots struggling to make their own decisions. Here are some simple tips as you learn to navigate your own way out there.
Preflight decision-making
For weather planning, try setting stringent personal minimums that you can gradually lower as you gain experience. I’ll pass along these words of wisdom from my private pilot DPE: “You would always rather be on the ground wishing you were in the air than in the air praying that you make it down safely.” Also, remember you can call 1-800-WX-BRIEF to speak to an actual human if you are unsure about the weather. On the other hand, aircraft airworthiness decisions can be a little trickier. Many flight schools now provide students with an electronic summary of the inspections rather than handing over their valuable maintenance logs. I understand the reasoning, but this practice makes it nearly impossible for a pilot to have a working knowledge of the required inspections and the various acceptable methods for determining airworthiness. If you don’t understand something in the logs, ask. And keep asking even if the mechanic or aircraft owner is offended by your questions. You have a right to fly a safe and legal aircraft, so know what the regulations say about the equipment and inspection requirements.
In-flight decision making
Many schools and instructors teach that their way to fly the airplane is the only way. We call that “technedure,” when someone claims their technique is the only proper procedure. Don’t be fooled. Yes, your school may require reading the checklist verbatim for the passenger and takeoff briefings. You must drop the flaps and gear at a specific point with a certain power setting in order to pass the requisite stage checks. But, my friends, that is only a place to start. At some point, the student becomes the PIC and needs to be able to think for himself.
Abnormal situations
If something breaks in the airplane, use your problem-solving skills to think of every solution, keeping in mind that FAR 91.3 allows for PIC authority to deviate from regulations for safety of flight. For example, a friend told me the story of his lost radios in instrument conditions. The regulations said to continue to his destination and squawk 7600. Instead, he used his cellphone to call ATC and work out a plan to descend for a nearby area of VFR rather than flying across the entire state of Tennessee NORDO.
Remember, no matter how much protective scaffolding you’ve had, it’s always a struggle learning to stand on your own. Give yourself some grace as you sort things out for yourself. After all, it’s the only way to learn.