Get extra lift from AOPA. Start your free membership trial today! Click here
Aircraft Spruce logo
Sponsored by Aircraft Spruce

Training and Safety Tip: Keep position reports simple

There’ve only been two times that I have been flat-out furious at other pilots sharing my airspace.

Photo by Chris Rose.

The first was when I was 17, working on my commercial pilot certificate. I was coming into a nontowered field for some landing practice and had my ears tuned to the traffic frequency inbound. Then, I made my 10-mile-out call, my 45-to-the-downwind call, and my downwind entry call.

Three seconds after my last transmission, another pilot made the exact same call. I frantically scanned for the traffic. I called the other pilot, and then, I saw his airplane’s shadow on my airplane’s nose. I chopped power. As the other airplane slid over my windshield I could see every speck of dirt on its belly. It was close enough that if I’d been in an open cockpit I could have checked the tire pressure.

The second time was just the other day when a pilot announced he was approximately ten-point-one miles northwest, inbound for landing. OK, I grant you, that’s hardly as big a deal as almost killing me. I guess with old age I’ve become less tolerant.

But my point is: Don’t let digital information make you dumb. First, there’s nothing approximate about a tenth of a nautical mile. That’s a very accurate measure of distance. To be precise, it’s 608 feet. Well, 607.61 feet for you decimal lovers. But more importantly, a decimal mile is sufficiently accurate that it’s completely inaccurate for aviation. Consider this: In a training airplane pouring on the coal at 100 knots, you’ll cross that decimal mile before you can finish your radio call, because you’re traveling “approximately” 168.78 feet per second—blowing through your tenth of a knot in less than four seconds.

Hopefully, by now you’re getting the idea. But just to be sure: Don’t use decimal points. At least not in your radio transmissions when reporting your distance. At airplane speeds, not only is decimal accuracy fundamentally inaccurate, it takes other pilots longer to mentally process a decimal number, which gives them headaches and makes them cranky. Not to mention it makes you sound like a fool. Adding, “approximately” to a decimal distance just compounds the sin.

So, keep it simple. Round up or down, and just tell me you’re approximately 10 miles out—and I’ll be happy.

William E. Dubois
William E. Dubois is a widely published aviation writer and columnist. He is an FAA Safety Team rep and a rare "double" Master Ground Instructor accredited by both NAFI and MICEP. An AOPA member since 1983, he holds a commercial pilot certificate and has a degree in aviation technology. He was recognized as a Distinguished Flight Instructor in the 2021 AOPA Flight Training Experience Awards.
Topics: Training and Safety, Student, Flight School
aircraft spruce logo

Aircraft Spruce

Sponsor of the AOPA Air Safety Institute's Training and Safety Tips
Aircraft Spruce provides virtually everything a pilot or aircraft owner might need. As a Strategic Partner since 2012, the company sponsors programs that bring hands-on knowledge and DIY spirit to AOPA members.