Get the latest news on coronavirus impacts on general aviation, including what AOPA is doing to protect GA, event cancellations, advice for pilots to protect themselves, and more. Read More
Already a member? Please login below for an enhanced experience. Not a member? Join today
Menu

Fresh perspective Fresh perspective

How graceful was that landing? Let’s review the footage.

Go out and make a dozen takeoffs and landings and they’re likely to run together in your mind. Some are better than others, but subtleties and trends are hard to identify.

Photography by the author
Photography by the author

Tiny point-of-view (POV) cameras can help students, instructors, and pilots seeking to sharpen their skills. The same gadgets that flood YouTube with content can also give pilots some valuable training tips—particularly in how to improve takeoffs and landings. Here are a couple of recent successes of the pilots I fly with that came about with the aid of a single GoPro camera.

First, the pilot of a new-to-him Mooney M20 Ovation was so bedeviled by landing difficulties—and so concerned about potential prop or tail strikes—that he was considering selling the airplane. I attached a camera to the belly of the airplane pointed forward, so its wide- angle lens captured all three tires as they contacted the runway (see “Unusual Attitude: See for Yourself,” December 2018 Flight Training ).

The pilot flew very well and was precisely on speed during his final approach. But the landing flare had no flare at all, and he touched down flat and let the airplane rock fore and aft as it decelerated. It was ghastly, and he really was in danger of a prop strike.

When I asked him how high off the ground the nosewheel had been at touchdown, he estimated it was at least six inches in the air. When we reviewed the video, however, he was shocked to see the nosewheel touching down at exactly the same moment as the main wheels. “That’s not at all how I remember it,” he said during the review session.

(Click on image for captions)

POV Landings

The shadow of a POV  camera (and the pole that it’s attached to) can be seen on the wing of this Van’s RV–4  in flight. Video can be extraordinarily helpful for pilots and instructors seeking to improve their performance. A tail-mounted POV camera provides a detailed view of what happens before and after the rubber meets the runway. The camera records ground track, lineup, flap position, lateral drift, and pitch attitude at touchdown—all of which can be reviewed and replayed  endlessly. On cold winter days like this, however, camera batteries can lose power quickly. (Note the pole-mounted POV camera on the left wing.)

The reason for his misperception is that the Mooney rests at a roughly 5-degree nose-up attitude on the ramp. It feels like it’s in a landing attitude when the wheels are on the ground. To get the airplane in the proper landing attitude requires an exaggerated nose-up attitude of approximately 10 degrees, and the pilot was reluctant to raise the nose that high because he was worried about dragging the tail.

Once he saw the video, his concern about a tail strike went away and he started making consistently excellent landings. The camera provided the proof he needed to see that his initial perception was wrong.

Next, I attached the cameras to a Cessna 180 Skywagon that AOPA Air Safety Institute Senior Vice President Richard McSpadden had recently begun flying. He felt confident flying the demanding airplane in light winds but wanted to gain experience in more challenging conditions. With a GoPro camera mounted a few inches ahead of the tailwheel and looking forward, the wide-angle lens showed both main wheels, and the wings from tip to tip.

McSpadden made four takeoffs and landings with a quartering headwind gusting to 20 knots. A second camera with audio recorded his comments and observations during the 45-minute flight. Afterward, I asked him what he expected to see on the video, and his answer was succinct and, as it turned out, accurate.

“I’m anticipating two good landings, two bad landings, and lots of bounces in between,” McSpadden said. “All of the touchdowns were left of the centerline, and most of them drifted further left on rollout.”

The camera captured pretty much exactly that.

McSpadden and I reviewed the video on a wide-screen monitor, and he’d slow it down and replay key sections. The audio was helpful, too, because it showed his perceptions of what the airplane was doing in the moment matched the reality of what was taking place where the rubber met the runway.

“I’m surprised that the bounces, on tape, don’t look as bad as they felt when they were actually happening,” the former U.S. Air Force pilot said. “I can see what I’ve got to do to eliminate them.”

There’s an old saying that every landing improves—in the pilot’s mind, anyway—the farther they taxi away from the touchdown zone. By the time they get to the ramp, just about every landing is perfectly fine. But POV cameras allow us to see things as they really happened. We can be clinical and dispassionate, and we don’t have to rely on our faulty memories. They call it a license to learn—and video from POV cameras can teach us a lot.

dave.hirschman@aopa.org

Dave Hirschman

Dave Hirschman

AOPA Pilot Editor at Large
AOPA Pilot Editor at Large Dave Hirschman joined AOPA in 2008. He has an airline transport pilot certificate and instrument and multiengine flight instructor certificates. Dave flies vintage, historical, and Experimental airplanes and specializes in tailwheel and aerobatic instruction.

Related Articles